I have been toying with the idea for over a year, wondering if I should do a dash cap, complete soft dash, or hard plastic dash.
I opted for the hard plastic dash and I am very pleased with the results.
Don't let the words "hard plastic dash" fool you into thinking it will look like a piece of crap. These dashes have a very nice textured finish on them, and a really good sheen -- not too glossy, not too flat.
The fit was excellent.
The whole job took me about 8.5 hours from start to finish.
Some notes and thoughts for those of you who are wondering what kind of task this is:
1) Be prepared to spend a lot of time fitting the glove box, glove box door, and glove box door latch You will definitely need a Dremel tool or equivalent to hog out some material as you fit the old brackets from the old dash onto the new one.
2) Removal and replacement of the dash is not as hard as others may lead you to believe. It took me about 45 minutes to get the old dash out of the car and onto the work bench.
3) I would think that trying to put a dash cap on and have it turn out nice would take as much or more time to perform than this complete dash replacement. I've seen some really nice dash cap jobs and some really horrible ones. I would recommend a complete dash replacement instead of a cap.
4) Label all of your wires and take photos of the electrical connections and you won't have any trouble re-assembling everything back in working order.
5) Anyone who rides in your car will be looking at the dash a lot. A crappy dash can ruin all of the other great aspects of your car. I waited too long to do this. I get a lot of flattering comments on my car when I take her out but when people used to look inside at the old dash, I could tell they were disappointed.
6) Bottom line -- if you are intimidated to tackle this task, it isn't as hard as you may think. The worst part was fitting the glove box components and even that wasn't too terrible.
Before and after photos, below:
Before:

After ( I need to paint the old sun-faded defroster vents black )


